42e législature, 1re session

Legislative

Assembly
of Ontario

Assemblée

législative
de l’Ontario


Votes and Proceedings

Procès-verbaux

No. 152

No 152

1st Session
42nd Parliament

1re session
42e législature

Thursday
March 5, 2020

Jeudi
5 mars 2020

9:00 A.M.
9 H
PRAYERS
PRIÈRES

ORDERS OF THE DAY

ORDRE DU JOUR

Second Reading of Bill 161, An Act to enact the Legal Aid Services Act, 2019 and to make various amendments to other Acts dealing with the courts and other justice matters.

Deuxième lecture du projet de loi 161, Loi visant à édicter la Loi de 2019 sur les services d’aide juridique et apportant diverses modifications à des lois traitant des tribunaux et d’autres questions relatives à la justice.

Debate resumed and after some time,

Le débat a repris et après quelque temps,

Ms. Skelly moved, under Standing Order 51 “That this question be now put”.

Mme Skelly propose, conformément à l’article 51 du Règlement « Que cette question soit maintenant mise aux voix ».

Vote deferred.

Le vote est différé.

Second Reading of Bill 175, An Act to amend and repeal various Acts respecting home care and community services.

Deuxième lecture du projet de loi 175, Loi modifiant et abrogeant diverses lois en ce qui concerne les services de soins à domicile et en milieu communautaire.

Debate resumed and after some time the debate adjourned at 10:15 a.m.

Le débat a repris et après quelque temps, à 10 h 15, le débat était ajourné.

10:15 A.M.
10 H 15

QUESTION PERIOD

PÉRIODE DE QUESTIONS

DEFERRED VOTES

VOTES DIFFÉRÉS

Motion for Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care (including supplementaries).

Motion portant l’adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère de la Santé et des Soins de longue durée (avec les supplémentaires).

Carried on the following division:-

Adoptée par le vote suivant :-

AYES / POUR - 66

Anand

Baber

Babikian

Bailey

Barrett

Bethlenfalvy

Bouma

Calandra

Cho (Scarborough North)

Cho (Willowdale)

Clark

Coe

Crawford

Cuzzeto

Fraser

Fullerton

Ghamari

Gill

Hardeman

Harris

Hogarth

Kanapathi

Karahalios

Ke

Kramp

Kusendova

Lecce

Martin

McNaughton

Miller (Parry Sound—Muskoka)

Mulroney

Nicholls

Oosterhoff

Pang

Park

Parsa

Pettapiece

Phillips

Piccini

Rasheed

Roberts

Romano

Sarkaria

Scott

Simard

Skelly

Smith (Bay of Quinte)

Smith (Peterborough—Kawartha)

Surma

Tangri

Thanigasalam

Thompson

Tibollo

Triantafilopoulos

Wai

Walker

AYES / POUR - Continued

Downey

Fedeli

Ford

Martow

McDonell

McKenna

Sabawy

Sandhu

Wynne

Yakabuski

NAYS / CONTRE - 37

Andrew

Armstrong

Arthur

Begum

Bell

Berns-McGown

Bisson

Bourgouin

Burch

Fife

French

Gates

Glover

Gretzky

Harden

Hassan

Hatfield

Kernaghan

Mamakwa

Mantha

Miller (Hamilton East—Stoney Creek)

Monteith-Farrell

Morrison

Natyshak

Rakocevic

Sattler

Schreiner

Shaw

Singh (Brampton Centre)

Singh (Brampton East)

Stevens

Stiles

Tabuns

Taylor

Vanthof

West

Yarde

And supply was accordingly concurred in.

En conséquence, le budget des dépenses est adopté.

Motion for Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Education (including supplementaries).

Motion portant l’adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère de l’Éducation (avec les supplémentaires).

Carried on the following division:-

Adoptée par le vote suivant :-

AYES / POUR - 66

Anand

Baber

Babikian

Bailey

Barrett

Bethlenfalvy

Bouma

Calandra

Cho (Scarborough North)

Cho (Willowdale)

Clark

Coe

Crawford

Cuzzeto

Downey

Fedeli

Ford

Fraser

Fullerton

Ghamari

Gill

Hardeman

Harris

Hogarth

Kanapathi

Karahalios

Ke

Kramp

Kusendova

Lecce

Martin

Martow

McDonell

McKenna

McNaughton

Miller (Parry Sound—Muskoka)

Mulroney

Nicholls

Oosterhoff

Pang

Park

Parsa

Pettapiece

Phillips

Piccini

Rasheed

Roberts

Romano

Sabawy

Sandhu

Sarkaria

Scott

Simard

Skelly

Smith (Bay of Quinte)

Smith (Peterborough—Kawartha)

Surma

Tangri

Thanigasalam

Thompson

Tibollo

Triantafilopoulos

Wai

Walker

Wynne

Yakabuski

NAYS / CONTRE - 37

Andrew

Armstrong

Arthur

Begum

Bell

Berns-McGown

Bisson

Bourgouin

French

Gates

Glover

Gretzky

Harden

Hassan

Hatfield

Kernaghan

Mantha

Miller (Hamilton East—Stoney Creek)

Monteith-Farrell

Morrison

Natyshak

Rakocevic

Sattler

Schreiner

Singh (Brampton Centre)

Singh (Brampton East)

Stevens

Stiles

Tabuns

Taylor

Vanthof

West

NAYS / CONTRE - Continued

Burch

Fife

Mamakwa

Shaw

Yarde

And supply was accordingly concurred in.

En conséquence, le budget des dépenses est adopté.

Motion for Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Transportation.

Motion portant l’adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère des Transports.

Carried on the following division:-

Adoptée par le vote suivant :-

AYES / POUR - 66

Anand

Baber

Babikian

Bailey

Barrett

Bethlenfalvy

Bouma

Calandra

Cho (Scarborough North)

Cho (Willowdale)

Clark

Coe

Crawford

Cuzzeto

Downey

Fedeli

Ford

Fraser

Fullerton

Ghamari

Gill

Hardeman

Harris

Hogarth

Kanapathi

Karahalios

Ke

Kramp

Kusendova

Lecce

Martin

Martow

McDonell

McKenna

McNaughton

Miller (Parry Sound—Muskoka)

Mulroney

Nicholls

Oosterhoff

Pang

Park

Parsa

Pettapiece

Phillips

Piccini

Rasheed

Roberts

Romano

Sabawy

Sandhu

Sarkaria

Scott

Simard

Skelly

Smith (Bay of Quinte)

Smith (Peterborough—Kawartha)

Surma

Tangri

Thanigasalam

Thompson

Tibollo

Triantafilopoulos

Wai

Walker

Wynne

Yakabuski

NAYS / CONTRE - 37

Andrew

Armstrong

Arthur

Begum

Bell

Berns-McGown

Bisson

Bourgouin

Burch

Fife

French

Gates

Glover

Gretzky

Harden

Hassan

Hatfield

Kernaghan

Mamakwa

Mantha

Miller (Hamilton East—Stoney Creek)

Monteith-Farrell

Morrison

Natyshak

Rakocevic

Sattler

Schreiner

Shaw

Singh (Brampton Centre)

Singh (Brampton East)

Stevens

Stiles

Tabuns

Taylor

Vanthof

West

Yarde

And supply was accordingly concurred in.

En conséquence, le budget des dépenses est adopté.

Motion for Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Infrastructure.

Motion portant l’adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère de l’Infrastructure.

Carried on the following division:-

Adoptée par le vote suivant :-

AYES / POUR - 66

Anand

Baber

Babikian

Bailey

Barrett

Bethlenfalvy

Bouma

Calandra

Cho (Scarborough North)

Cho (Willowdale)

Clark

Coe

Crawford

Cuzzeto

Downey

Fedeli

Ford

Fraser

Fullerton

Ghamari

Gill

Hardeman

Harris

Hogarth

Kanapathi

Karahalios

Ke

Kramp

Kusendova

Lecce

Martin

Martow

McDonell

McKenna

McNaughton

Miller (Parry Sound—Muskoka)

Mulroney

Nicholls

Oosterhoff

Pang

Park

Parsa

Pettapiece

Phillips

Piccini

Rasheed

Roberts

Romano

Sabawy

Sandhu

Sarkaria

Scott

Simard

Skelly

Smith (Bay of Quinte)

Smith (Peterborough—Kawartha)

Surma

Tangri

Thanigasalam

Thompson

Tibollo

Triantafilopoulos

Wai

Walker

Wynne

Yakabuski

NAYS / CONTRE - 37

Andrew

Armstrong

Arthur

Begum

Bell

Berns-McGown

Bisson

Bourgouin

Burch

Fife

French

Gates

Glover

Gretzky

Harden

Hassan

Hatfield

Kernaghan

Mamakwa

Mantha

Miller (Hamilton East—Stoney Creek)

Monteith-Farrell

Morrison

Natyshak

Rakocevic

Sattler

Schreiner

Shaw

Singh (Brampton Centre)

Singh (Brampton East)

Stevens

Stiles

Tabuns

Taylor

Vanthof

West

Yarde

And supply was accordingly concurred in.

En conséquence, le budget des dépenses est adopté.

Motion for Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Children, Community and Social Services (including supplementaries).

Motion portant l’adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère des Services à l’enfance et des Services sociaux et communautaires (avec les supplémentaires).

Carried on the following division:-

Adoptée par le vote suivant :-

AYES / POUR - 66

Anand

Baber

Babikian

Bailey

Barrett

Bethlenfalvy

Bouma

Calandra

Cho (Scarborough North)

Cho (Willowdale)

Clark

Coe

Fraser

Fullerton

Ghamari

Gill

Hardeman

Harris

Hogarth

Kanapathi

Karahalios

Ke

Kramp

Kusendova

McNaughton

Miller (Parry Sound—Muskoka)

Mulroney

Nicholls

Oosterhoff

Pang

Park

Parsa

Pettapiece

Phillips

Piccini

Rasheed

Sarkaria

Scott

Simard

Skelly

Smith (Bay of Quinte)

Smith (Peterborough—Kawartha)

Surma

Tangri

Thanigasalam

Thompson

Tibollo

Triantafilopoulos

AYES / POUR - Continued

Crawford

Cuzzeto

Downey

Fedeli

Ford

Lecce

Martin

Martow

McDonell

McKenna

Roberts

Romano

Sabawy

Sandhu

Wai

Walker

Wynne

Yakabuski

NAYS / CONTRE - 37

Andrew

Armstrong

Arthur

Begum

Bell

Berns-McGown

Bisson

Bourgouin

Burch

Fife

French

Gates

Glover

Gretzky

Harden

Hassan

Hatfield

Kernaghan

Mamakwa

Mantha

Miller (Hamilton East—Stoney Creek)

Monteith-Farrell

Morrison

Natyshak

Rakocevic

Sattler

Schreiner

Shaw

Singh (Brampton Centre)

Singh (Brampton East)

Stevens

Stiles

Tabuns

Taylor

Vanthof

West

Yarde

And supply was accordingly concurred in.

En conséquence, le budget des dépenses est adopté.

Motion for Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of the Environment, Conservation and Parks.

Motion portant l’adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère de l’Environnement, de la Protection de la nature et des Parcs.

Carried on the following division:-

Adoptée par le vote suivant :-

AYES / POUR - 66

Anand

Baber

Babikian

Bailey

Barrett

Bethlenfalvy

Bouma

Calandra

Cho (Scarborough North)

Cho (Willowdale)

Clark

Coe

Crawford

Cuzzeto

Downey

Fedeli

Ford

Fraser

Fullerton

Ghamari

Gill

Hardeman

Harris

Hogarth

Kanapathi

Karahalios

Ke

Kramp

Kusendova

Lecce

Martin

Martow

McDonell

McKenna

McNaughton

Miller (Parry Sound—Muskoka)

Mulroney

Nicholls

Oosterhoff

Pang

Park

Parsa

Pettapiece

Phillips

Piccini

Rasheed

Roberts

Romano

Sabawy

Sandhu

Sarkaria

Scott

Simard

Skelly

Smith (Bay of Quinte)

Smith (Peterborough—Kawartha)

Surma

Tangri

Thanigasalam

Thompson

Tibollo

Triantafilopoulos

Wai

Walker

Wynne

Yakabuski

NAYS / CONTRE - 37

Andrew

Armstrong

Arthur

Begum

Bell

Berns-McGown

French

Gates

Glover

Gretzky

Harden

Hassan

Mantha

Miller (Hamilton East—Stoney Creek)

Monteith-Farrell

Morrison

Natyshak

Rakocevic

Singh (Brampton Centre)

Singh (Brampton East)

Stevens

Stiles

Tabuns

Taylor

NAYS / CONTRE - Continued

Bisson

Bourgouin

Burch

Fife

Hatfield

Kernaghan

Mamakwa

Sattler

Schreiner

Shaw

Vanthof

West

Yarde

And supply was accordingly concurred in.

En conséquence, le budget des dépenses est adopté.

Motion for Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs (including supplementaries).

Motion portant l’adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère de l’Agriculture, de l’Alimentation et des Affaires rurales (avec les supplémentaires).

Carried on the following division:-

Adoptée par le vote suivant :-

AYES / POUR - 66

Anand

Baber

Babikian

Bailey

Barrett

Bethlenfalvy

Bouma

Calandra

Cho (Scarborough North)

Cho (Willowdale)

Clark

Coe

Crawford

Cuzzeto

Downey

Fedeli

Ford

Fraser

Fullerton

Ghamari

Gill

Hardeman

Harris

Hogarth

Kanapathi

Karahalios

Ke

Kramp

Kusendova

Lecce

Martin

Martow

McDonell

McKenna

McNaughton

Miller (Parry Sound—Muskoka)

Mulroney

Nicholls

Oosterhoff

Pang

Park

Parsa

Pettapiece

Phillips

Piccini

Rasheed

Roberts

Romano

Sabawy

Sandhu

Sarkaria

Scott

Simard

Skelly

Smith (Bay of Quinte)

Smith (Peterborough—Kawartha)

Surma

Tangri

Thanigasalam

Thompson

Tibollo

Triantafilopoulos

Wai

Walker

Wynne

Yakabuski

NAYS / CONTRE - 37

Andrew

Armstrong

Arthur

Begum

Bell

Berns-McGown

Bisson

Bourgouin

Burch

Fife

French

Gates

Glover

Gretzky

Harden

Hassan

Hatfield

Kernaghan

Mamakwa

Mantha

Miller (Hamilton East—Stoney Creek)

Monteith-Farrell

Morrison

Natyshak

Rakocevic

Sattler

Schreiner

Shaw

Singh (Brampton Centre)

Singh (Brampton East)

Stevens

Stiles

Tabuns

Taylor

Vanthof

West

Yarde

And supply was accordingly concurred in.

En conséquence, le budget des dépenses est adopté.

Motion for closure on Second Reading of Bill 161, An Act to enact the Legal Aid Services Act, 2019 and to make various amendments to other Acts dealing with the courts and other justice matters.

Carried on the following division:-

Adoptée par le vote suivant :-

AYES / POUR - 64

Anand

Baber

Babikian

Bailey

Barrett

Bethlenfalvy

Bouma

Calandra

Cho (Scarborough North)

Cho (Willowdale)

Clark

Coe

Crawford

Cuzzeto

Downey

Dunlop

Fedeli

Ford

Fullerton

Ghamari

Gill

Hardeman

Harris

Hogarth

Kanapathi

Karahalios

Ke

Kramp

Kusendova

Lecce

Martin

Martow

McDonell

McKenna

McNaughton

Miller (Parry Sound—Muskoka)

Mulroney

Nicholls

Oosterhoff

Pang

Park

Parsa

Pettapiece

Phillips

Piccini

Rasheed

Roberts

Romano

Sabawy

Sandhu

Sarkaria

Scott

Skelly

Smith (Bay of Quinte)

Smith (Peterborough—Kawartha)

Surma

Tangri

Thanigasalam

Thompson

Tibollo

Triantafilopoulos

Wai

Walker

Yakabuski

NAYS / CONTRE - 40

Andrew

Armstrong

Arthur

Begum

Bell

Berns-McGown

Bisson

Bourgouin

Burch

Fife

Fraser

French

Gates

Glover

Gretzky

Harden

Hassan

Hatfield

Kernaghan

Mamakwa

Mantha

Miller (Hamilton East—Stoney Creek)

Monteith-Farrell

Morrison

Natyshak

Rakocevic

Sattler

Schreiner

Shaw

Simard

Singh (Brampton Centre)

Singh (Brampton East)

Stevens

Stiles

Tabuns

Taylor

Vanthof

West

Wynne

Yarde

The question was then put.

La question a ensuite été mise aux voix.

Second Reading of Bill 161, An Act to enact the Legal Aid Services Act, 2019 and to make various amendments to other Acts dealing with the courts and other justice matters.

Deuxième lecture du projet de loi 161, Loi visant à édicter la Loi de 2019 sur les services d’aide juridique et apportant diverses modifications à des lois traitant des tribunaux et d’autres questions relatives à la justice.

Carried on the following division:-

Adoptée par le vote suivant :-

AYES / POUR - 64

Anand

Baber

Babikian

Bailey

Barrett

Bethlenfalvy

Bouma

Calandra

Cho (Scarborough North)

Cho (Willowdale)

Fedeli

Ford

Fullerton

Ghamari

Gill

Hardeman

Harris

Hogarth

Kanapathi

Karahalios

McDonell

McKenna

McNaughton

Miller (Parry Sound—Muskoka)

Mulroney

Nicholls

Oosterhoff

Pang

Park

Parsa

Sabawy

Sandhu

Sarkaria

Scott

Skelly

Smith (Bay of Quinte)

Smith (Peterborough—Kawartha)

Surma

Tangri

Thanigasalam

AYES / POUR - Continued

Clark

Coe

Crawford

Cuzzeto

Downey

Dunlop

Ke

Kramp

Kusendova

Lecce

Martin

Martow

Pettapiece

Phillips

Piccini

Rasheed

Roberts

Romano

Thompson

Tibollo

Triantafilopoulos

Wai

Walker

Yakabuski

NAYS / CONTRE - 40

Andrew

Armstrong

Arthur

Begum

Bell

Berns-McGown

Bisson

Bourgouin

Burch

Fife

Fraser

French

Gates

Glover

Gretzky

Harden

Hassan

Hatfield

Kernaghan

Mamakwa

Mantha

Miller (Hamilton East—Stoney Creek)

Monteith-Farrell

Morrison

Natyshak

Rakocevic

Sattler

Schreiner

Shaw

Simard

Singh (Brampton Centre)

Singh (Brampton East)

Stevens

Stiles

Tabuns

Taylor

Vanthof

West

Wynne

Yarde

Referred to the Standing Committee on Justice Policy.

Renvoyé au Comité permanent de la justice.

The House recessed at 11:57 a.m.

À 11 h 57, l’Assemblée a suspendu la séance.

1:00 P.M.
13 H

PETITIONS

PÉTITIONS

Highway of Heroes tree campaign (Sessional Paper No. P-110) Mr. Hatfield.

Full-day kindergarten (Sessional Paper No. P-112) Mr. Tabuns.

Winter road maintenance on Highways 11 and 17 (Sessional Paper No. P-169) Mr. Mantha.

Housing and shelter support in London (Sessional Paper No. P-179) Ms. Armstrong.

Transit infrastructure projects (Sessional Paper No. P-213) Mr. Baber, Ms. Hogarth, Ms. Kusendova and Mr. Sandhu.

Phone access for prisoners (Sessional Paper No. P-215) Ms. Berns-McGown and Mr. Harden.

Food Day Ontario (Sessional Paper No. P-220) Mr. Babikian and Mrs. Karahalios.

PRIVATE MEMBERS’ PUBLIC BUSINESS

AFFAIRES D’INTÉRÊT PUBLIC ÉMANANT DES DÉPUTÉES ET DÉPUTÉS

Ms. Park moved,

Mme Park propose,

Private Members’ Notice of Motion No. 91:-

Avis de motion émanant des députées et députés no 91 :-

That, in the opinion of this House, the Government of Ontario should include nuclear energy and the development of Small Modular Reactors as a clean energy option in its environment, climate change and clean energy planning and policies.

Debate arose and after some time,

Il s’élève un débat et après quelque temps,

Carried on the following division:-

Adoptée par le vote suivant :-

AYES / POUR - 59

Baber

Babikian

Bailey

Barrett

Bethlenfalvy

Bouma

Calandra

Cho (Scarborough North)

Cho (Willowdale)

Clark

Coe

Crawford

Cuzzeto

Downey

Ghamari

Gill

Hardeman

Harris

Hogarth

Kanapathi

Karahalios

Ke

Khanjin

Kusendova

Lecce

MacLeod

Martin

Martow

McDonell

McKenna

McNaughton

Miller (Parry Sound—Muskoka)

Mulroney

Nicholls

Oosterhoff

Pang

Park

Parsa

Pettapiece

Piccini

Rasheed

Roberts

Romano

Sabawy

Sandhu

Sarkaria

Scott

Skelly

Smith (Peterborough—Kawartha)

Surma

Tangri

Thanigasalam

Thompson

Tibollo

Triantafilopoulos

Wai

Walker

Wynne

Yakabuski

NAYS / CONTRE - 18

Berns-McGown

Bisson

Bourgouin

Glover

Harden

Hassan

Hatfield

Mamakwa

Morrison

Rakocevic

Sattler

Schreiner

Shaw

Singh (Brampton Centre)

Stevens

Stiles

Tabuns

Vanthof

Mr. Barrett moved,

M. Barrett propose,

Second Reading of Bill 166, An Act to amend the Great Lakes Protection Act, 2015.

Deuxième lecture du projet de loi 166, Loi modifiant la Loi de 2015 sur la protection des Grands Lacs.

Debate arose and after some time,

Il s’élève un débat et après quelque temps,

Carried.

Adoptée.

Referred to the Standing Committee on Regulations and Private Bills.

Renvoyé au Comité permanent des règlements et des projets de loi d’intérêt privé.

Mr. Hillier moved,

M. Hillier propose,

Private Members’ Notice of Motion No. 93:-

Avis de motion émanant des députées et députés no 93 :-

That, in the opinion of this House, the Standing Orders of the Legislative Assembly be amended to provide for the establishment of a Standing Committee on Indigenous Relations to investigate matters related to Indigenous affairs, address complaints and provide recommendations on Indigenous policy; and

That the membership of the Committee include members from all recognized parties, including Independent Members; and

That the Chair of the Committee shall not be a member of the governing party; and

That the Committee shall focus on specific issues of concern, including but not limited to:

1. Indigenous land claims;

2. Indigenous treaties;

3. Provision of provincial services on reserves;

4. Indigenous impact benefit agreements;

5. Development of resources on native lands;

6. Education and curriculum; and

That all Bills and regulations that affect Indigenous peoples be referred to this Committee; and

That the House is excluded from referring Bills at Second Reading that do not relate to Indigenous policy to the Committee; and

That the Committee shall be empowered to review and report to the House its observations, opinions and recommendations on any issues relating to Indigenous policy.

Debate arose and after some time,

Il s’élève un débat et après quelque temps,

Carried.

Adoptée.

ORDERS OF THE DAY

ORDRE DU JOUR

Second Reading of Bill 159, An Act to amend various statutes in respect of consumer protection.

Deuxième lecture du projet de loi 159, Loi modifiant diverses lois en ce qui concerne la protection du consommateur.

Debate arose and after some time the House adjourned at 6:00 p.m.

Il s’élève un débat et après quelque temps, à 18 h, l’Assemblée a ajourné ses travaux.

le président

Ted Arnott

Speaker

RESPONSES TO PETITIONS

RÉPONSES AUX PÉTITIONS

Ontario Disability Support Program (Sessional Paper No. P-5):

(Tabled November 21, 2019) Miss Taylor.

911 Emergency response coverage (Sessional Paper No. P-72):

(Tabled November 21, 2019) Mme Gélinas.

Post secondary education (Sessional Paper No. P-130):

(Tabled November 21, 2019) Ms. Berns-McGown.

Animal welfare (Sessional Paper No. P-178):

(Tabled November 21, 2019) Ms. Hogarth.