37e législature, 4e session

LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY OF ONTARIO

ASSEMBLÉE LÉGISLATIVE DE L'ONTARIO

Tuesday 3 June 2003 Mardi 3 juin 2003

ORDERS OF THE DAY

BACK TO SCHOOL
(TORONTO CATHOLIC ELEMENTARY) AND EDUCATION AND PROVINCIAL SCHOOLS NEGOTIATIONS AMENDMENT ACT, 2003 /
LOI DE 2003 PRÉVOYANT LE RETOUR
À L'ÉCOLE (SECTEUR ÉLÉMENTAIRE DU CONSEIL CATHOLIQUE DE TORONTO)
ET MODIFIANT LA LOI SUR L'ÉDUCATION ET LA LOI SUR
LA NÉGOCIATION COLLECTIVE DANS LES ÉCOLES PROVINCIALES

BACK TO SCHOOL
(TORONTO CATHOLIC ELEMENTARY) AND EDUCATION AND PROVINCIAL SCHOOLS NEGOTIATIONS AMENDMENT ACT, 2003 /
LOI DE 2003 PRÉVOYANT LE RETOUR
À L'ÉCOLE (SECTEUR ÉLÉMENTAIRE DU CONSEIL CATHOLIQUE DE TORONTO)
ET MODIFIANT LA LOI SUR L'ÉDUCATION ET LA LOI SUR
LA NÉGOCIATION COLLECTIVE DANS LES ÉCOLES PROVINCIALES


Tuesday 3 June 2003 Mardi 3 juin 2003

Report continued from volume A.

ORDERS OF THE DAY

BACK TO SCHOOL
(TORONTO CATHOLIC ELEMENTARY) AND EDUCATION AND PROVINCIAL SCHOOLS NEGOTIATIONS AMENDMENT ACT, 2003 /
LOI DE 2003 PRÉVOYANT LE RETOUR
À L'ÉCOLE (SECTEUR ÉLÉMENTAIRE DU CONSEIL CATHOLIQUE DE TORONTO)
ET MODIFIANT LA LOI SUR L'ÉDUCATION ET LA LOI SUR
LA NÉGOCIATION COLLECTIVE DANS LES ÉCOLES PROVINCIALES

Resuming the debate adjourned on May 29, 2003, on the motion for second reading of Bill 28, An Act to resolve a labour dispute between the Ontario English Catholic Teachers' Association and the Toronto Catholic District School Board and to amend the Education Act and the Provincial Schools Negotiations Act / Projet de loi 28, Loi visant à régler le conflit de travail opposant l'Association des enseignantes et des enseignants catholiques anglo-ontariens et le conseil scolaire de district appelé Toronto Catholic District School Board et modifiant la Loi sur l'éducation et la Loi sur la négociation collective dans les écoles provinciales.

The Acting Speaker (Mr Michael A. Brown): Pursuant to the order of the House dated June 2, 2003, I am now required to put the question.

Mr Clark has moved second reading of Bill 28, An Act to resolve a labour dispute between the Ontario English Catholic Teachers' Association and the Toronto Catholic District School Board and to amend the Education Act and the Provincial Schools Negotiations Act.

Is it the pleasure of the House that the motion carry?

All those in favour will say "aye."

All those opposed will say "nay."

In my opinion, the ayes have it.

Call in the members. This will be a five-minute bell.

The division bells rang from 1819 to 1824.

The Acting Speaker: All those in favour will please rise one at a time and be recognized by the Clerk.

Ayes

Arnott, Ted

Baird, John R.

Barrett, Toby

Beaubien, Marcel

Chudleigh, Ted

Clark, Brad

Clement, Tony

Coburn, Brian

Cunningham, Dianne

DeFaria, Carl

Dunlop, Garfield

Ecker, Janet

Elliott, Brenda

Eves, Ernie

Flaherty, Jim

Galt, Doug

Gilchrist, Steve

Gill, Raminder

Guzzo, Garry J.

Hardeman, Ernie

Hastings, John

Hudak, Tim

Jackson, Cameron

Johns, Helen

Johnson, Bert

Kells, Morley

Klees, Frank

Marland, Margaret

Martiniuk, Gerry

Maves, Bart

Mazzilli, Frank

McDonald, AL

Miller, Norm

Molinari, Tina R.

Munro, Julia

Murdoch, Bill

Mushinski, Marilyn

Newman, Dan

O'Toole, John

Ouellette, Jerry J.

Runciman, Robert W.

Sampson, Rob

Spina, Joseph

Sterling, Norman W.

Stewart, R. Gary

Stockwell, Chris

Tascona, Joseph N.

Tsubouchi, David H.

Turnbull, David

Wettlaufer, Wayne

Wilson, Jim

Witmer, Elizabeth

Wood, Bob

Young, David

The Acting Speaker: All those opposed will please rise one at a time and be recognized by the Clerk.

Nays

Agostino, Dominic

Bartolucci, Rick

Bisson, Gilles

Boyer, Claudette

Bradley, James J.

Bryant, Michael

Caplan, David

Churley, Marilyn

Cleary, John C.

Colle, Mike

Cordiano, Joseph

Crozier, Bruce

Curling, Alvin

Di Cocco, Caroline

Dombrowsky, Leona

Duncan, Dwight

Gerretsen, John

Gravelle, Michael

Hampton, Howard

Hoy, Pat

Kennedy, Gerard

Kormos, Peter

Kwinter, Monte

Lalonde, Jean-Marc

Marchese, Rosario

Martel, Shelley

Martin, Tony

McGuinty, Dalton

McLeod, Lyn

McMeekin, Ted

Parsons, Ernie

Patten, Richard

Peters, Steve

Phillips, Gerry

Prue, Michael

Pupatello, Sandra

Ramsay, David

Sergio, Mario

Smitherman, George

Sorbara, Greg

Clerk of the House (Mr Claude L. DesRosiers): The ayes are 54; the nays are 40.

The Acting Speaker: I declare the motion carried.

BACK TO SCHOOL
(TORONTO CATHOLIC ELEMENTARY) AND EDUCATION AND PROVINCIAL SCHOOLS NEGOTIATIONS AMENDMENT ACT, 2003 /
LOI DE 2003 PRÉVOYANT LE RETOUR
À L'ÉCOLE (SECTEUR ÉLÉMENTAIRE DU CONSEIL CATHOLIQUE DE TORONTO)
ET MODIFIANT LA LOI SUR L'ÉDUCATION ET LA LOI SUR
LA NÉGOCIATION COLLECTIVE DANS LES ÉCOLES PROVINCIALES

Mr Clark, on behalf of Mr Eves, moved third reading of the following bill:

Bill 28, An Act to resolve a labour dispute between the Ontario English Catholic Teachers' Association and the Toronto Catholic District School Board and to amend the Education Act and the Provincial Schools Negotiations Act / Projet de loi 28, Loi visant à régler le conflit de travail opposant l'Association des enseignantes et des enseignants catholiques anglo-ontariens et le conseil scolaire de district appelé Toronto Catholic District School Board et modifiant la Loi sur l'éducation et la Loi sur la négociation collective dans les écoles provinciales.

The Acting Speaker (Mr Michael A. Brown): Pursuant to the order of the House dated June 2, 2003, I am now required to put the question.

All those in favour will say "aye."

All those opposed will say "nay."

In my opinion, the ayes have it.

Call in the members. This will be a five-minute bell.

The division bells rang from 1827 to 1832.

The Acting Speaker: Order. Those in the galleries have to understand that you are guests here. We appreciate your assistance during our proceedings. No one can participate other than members here on the floor, so we appreciate your help.

Mr Clark has moved third reading of Bill 28. All those in favour will rise one at a time and be recognized by the Clerk.

Ayes

Arnott, Ted

Baird, John R.

Barrett, Toby

Beaubien, Marcel

Chudleigh, Ted

Clark, Brad

Clement, Tony

Coburn, Brian

Cunningham, Dianne

DeFaria, Carl

Dunlop, Garfield

Ecker, Janet

Elliott, Brenda

Eves, Ernie

Flaherty, Jim

Galt, Doug

Gilchrist, Steve

Gill, Raminder

Guzzo, Garry J.

Hardeman, Ernie

Hastings, John

Hudak, Tim

Jackson, Cameron

Johns, Helen

Johnson, Bert

Kells, Morley

Klees, Frank

Marland, Margaret

Martiniuk, Gerry

Maves, Bart

Mazzilli, Frank

McDonald, AL

Miller, Norm

Molinari, Tina R.

Munro, Julia

Murdoch, Bill

Mushinski, Marilyn

Newman, Dan

O'Toole, John

Ouellette, Jerry J.

Runciman, Robert W.

Sampson, Rob

Spina, Joseph

Sterling, Norman W.

Stewart, R. Gary

Stockwell, Chris

Tascona, Joseph N.

Tsubouchi, David H.

Turnbull, David

Wettlaufer, Wayne

Wilson, Jim

Witmer, Elizabeth

Wood, Bob

Young, David

The Acting Speaker: All those opposed will please rise one at a time and be recognized by the Clerk.

Nays

Agostino, Dominic

Bartolucci, Rick

Bisson, Gilles

Boyer, Claudette

Bradley, James J.

Bryant, Michael

Caplan, David

Churley, Marilyn

Cleary, John C.

Colle, Mike

Cordiano, Joseph

Crozier, Bruce

Curling, Alvin

Di Cocco, Caroline

Dombrowsky, Leona

Duncan, Dwight

Gerretsen, John

Gravelle, Michael

Hampton, Howard

Hoy, Pat

Kennedy, Gerard

Kormos, Peter

Kwinter, Monte

Lalonde, Jean-Marc

Marchese, Rosario

Martel, Shelley

Martin, Tony

McGuinty, Dalton

McLeod, Lyn

McMeekin, Ted

Parsons, Ernie

Patten, Richard

Peters, Steve

Phillips, Gerry

Prue, Michael

Pupatello, Sandra

Ramsay, David

Sergio, Mario

Smitherman, George

Sorbara, Greg

Clerk of the House (Mr Claude L. DesRosiers): The ayes are 54; the nays are 40.

The Acting Speaker: I declare the motion carried.

Be it resolved that the bill do now pass and be entitled as in the motion.

It being well past 6 of the clock, this House stands adjourned until 1:30 of the clock tomorrow afternoon.

The House adjourned at 1835.