• Carried
• Ordered for Second Reading

Principal Debaters

• Calandra, Hon. Paul
  Markham—Stouffville
• Flack, Hon. Rob
  Elgin—Middlesex—London
• Hogarth, Christine
  Etobicoke—Lakeshore
• Rae, Matthew
  Perth—Wellington

Questions and Responses

• Byers, Rick
  Bruce—Grey—Owen Sound
• Gélinas, France
  Nickel Belt
• Harden, Joel
  Ottawa Centre
• Pierre, Natalie
  Burlington
• West, Jamie
  Sudbury

Principal Debaters

• Bell, Jessica
  University—Rosedale
• Gates, Wayne
  Niagara Falls
• Harden, Joel
  Ottawa Centre
• Kernaghan, Terence
  London North Centre
• McCarthy, Hon. Todd
  Durham
• Oosterhoff, Sam
  Niagara West
• Sabawy, Sheref
  Mississauga—Erin Mills
• Schreiner, Mike
  Guelph
• Shamji, Adil
  Don Valley East

Questions and Responses

• Andrew, Jill
  Toronto—St. Paul's
• Armstrong, Teresa
  London—Fanshawe
• Bourgouin, Guy
  Mushkegowuk—James Bay
• Byers, Rick
  Bruce—Grey—Owen Sound
• Calandra, Hon. Paul
  Markham—Stouffville
• Fife, Catherine
  Waterloo
• Flack, Hon. Rob
  Elgin—Middlesex—London
• Fraser, John
  Ottawa South
• French, Jennifer
  Oshawa
• Harris, Mike
  Kitchener—Conestoga
• Holland, Kevin
  Thunder Bay—Atikokan
• Hsu, Ted
  Kingston and the Islands
• Jones, Trevor
  Chatham-Kent—Leamington
• Kanapathi, Logan
  Markham—Thornhill
• Leardi, Anthony
  Essex
• Rae, Matthew
  Perth—Wellington
• Shaw, Sandy
  Hamilton West—Ancaster—Dundas
• Smith, Dave
  Peterborough—Kawartha

Principal Debaters

• Armstrong, Teresa
  London—Fanshawe
• Burch, Jeff
  Niagara Centre
• Cuzzetto, Rudy
  Mississauga—Lakeshore
• Fraser, John
  Ottawa South
• Leardi, Anthony
  Essex
• MacLeod, Lisa
  Nepean
• McMahon, Mary-Margaret
  Beaches—East York
• Rakocevic, Tom
  Humber River—Black Creek
• Tangri, Hon. Nina
  Mississauga—Streetsville
• Taylor, Monique
  Hamilton Mountain
• Vaugeois, Lise
  Thunder Bay—Superior North

Questions and Responses

• Andrew, Jill
  Toronto—St. Paul's
• Bell, Jessica
  University—Rosedale
• Blais, Stephen
  Orléans
• Bresee, Ric
  Hastings—Lennox and Addington
• Calandra, Hon. Paul
  Markham—Stouffville
• Coe, Lorne
  Whitby
• Dixon, Jess
  Kitchener South—Hespeler
• Jones, Trevor
  Chatham-Kent—Leamington
• Kernaghan, Terence
  London North Centre
• Khanjin, Hon. Andrea
  Barrie—Innisfil
• McGregor, Graham
  Brampton North
• Rae, Matthew
  Perth—Wellington
• Riddell, Brian
  Cambridge
• Sabawy, Sheref
  Mississauga—Erin Mills
• Saunderson, Brian
  Simcoe—Grey

• Debated
• Moved closure
• Closure carried on division
• Question put

• Carried on division
• Ordered referred to Standing Committee
  Standing Committee on Finance and Economic Affairs