37e législature, 3e session

No. 70

No 70

Votes and Proceedings

Procès-verbaux

Legislative Assembly
of Ontario

Assemblée législative
de l'Ontario

Tuesday
December 10, 2002


Daytime Meeting - Sessional Day 123
Evening Meeting - Sessional Day 124

Mardi
10 décembre 2002


Séance de l'après-midi - jour de session 123
Séance du soir - jour de session 124

3rd Session,
37th Parliament

3e session
37e législature

PRAYERS
1:30 P.M.

PRIÈRES
13 H 30

The Speaker addressed the House as follows:-

Standing Order 62(a) provides that "the Standing Committee on Estimates shall present one report with respect to all of the Estimates and Supplementary Estimates considered pursuant to Standing Orders 59 and 61 no later than the third Thursday in November of each calendar year".

The House not having received a report from the Standing Committee on Estimates for certain ministries on Thursday, November 21, 2002, as required by the Standing Orders of this House, pursuant to Standing Order 62(b) the Supplementary Estimates before the Committee of the Ministry of Community, Family and Children's Services, the Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care, the Ministry of Northern Development and Mines, and the Ministry of Training, Colleges and Universities are deemed to be passed by the Committee and are deemed to be reported to and received by the House.

Accordingly, the Supplementary Estimates (2002-2003) of the following ministries were deemed to be passed by the Standing Committee on Estimates and were deemed to be reported to and received by the House:-

MINISTRY OF COMMUNITY, FAMILY AND CHILDREN'S SERVICES

(SUPPLEMENTARY ESTIMATES ONLY)

702

Adults' and Children's Services Program

$

153,900,000

MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND LONG TERM CARE

(SUPPLEMENTARY ESTIMATES ONLY)

1404

Integrated Health Care Program

$

350,000,000

MINISTRY OF NORTHERN DEVELOPMENT AND MINES

(SUPPLEMENTARY ESTIMATES ONLY)

2202

Northern Development Program

$

21,600,000

MINISTRY OF TRAINING, COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES

(SUPPLEMENTARY ESTIMATES ONLY)

3002

Postsecondary Education Program

$

10,000,000

REPORTS BY COMMITTEES

RAPPORTS DES COMITÉS

Mr. Curling from the Standing Committee on Estimates presented the Committee's report as follows:-

Pursuant to Standing Order 60(a), the following Estimates (2002-2003) are reported back to the House as they were not previously selected by the Committee for consideration and are deemed to be received and concurred in:-

OFFICE OF THE ASSEMBLY

201

202

Office of the Assembly Program

Commission(er)'s Program

$$

74,878,000

7,515,200

OFFICE OF THE CHIEF ELECTION OFFICER

501

Office of the Chief Election Officer Program

$

1,959,300

OMBUDSMAN ONTARIO

2301

Ombudsman Ontario Program

$

6,093,400

OFFICE OF THE PROVINCIAL AUDITOR

2501

Office of the Provincial Auditor Program

$

6,253,400

Pursuant to Standing Order 61(c), the Supplementary Estimates (2002-2003) of the following ministries and offices not selected for consideration are deemed passed by the Committee and reported to the House in accordance with the terms of the Standing Order and are deemed to be received and concurred in:-

MANAGEMENT BOARD SECRETARIAT

(SUPPLEMENTARY ESTIMATES ONLY)

1803

Corporate Controllership Program

$

400,000,000

MINISTRY OF TRANSPORTATION

(SUPPLEMENTARY ESTIMATES ONLY)

2702

2704

Transportation Policy and Planning Program

Provincial Highways Management Program

$

$

62,300,000

78,400,000

INTRODUCTION OF BILLS

DÉPÔT DES PROJETS DE LOI

The following Bills were introduced and read the first time:-

Les projets de loi suivants sont présentés et lus une première fois:-

Bill 224, An Act to amend the Condominium Act, 1998 to limit the use of condominiums by transient tenants. Mr. Smitherman.

Projet de loi 224, Loi modifiant la Loi de 1998 sur les condominiums afin de limiter l'usage des condominiums par des locataires de passage. M. Smitherman.

Bill 225, An Act to amend the Electricity Act, 1998. Mr. Lalonde.

Projet de loi 225, Loi modifiant la Loi de 1998 sur l'électricité. M. Lalonde.

Bill 226, An Act in memory of Jay Lawrence and Bart Mackey to amend the Highway Traffic Act. Mr. McDonald.

Projet de loi 226, Loi modifiant le Code de la route à la mémoire de Jay Lawrence et Bart Mackey. M. McDonald.

Bill 227, An Act to amend the Food Safety and Quality Act, 2001. Mr. Peters.

Projet de loi 227, Loi modifiant la Loi de 2001 sur la qualité et la salubrité des aliments. M. Peters.

MOTIONS

MOTIONS

Mr. Stockwell moved,

M. Stockwell propose,

That notwithstanding the motion passed by the House on Monday, November 18, 2002, pursuant to Standing Order 9 (c)(ii), the House shall meet from 6:45 p.m. to midnight on Tuesday, December 10, 2002, Wednesday, December 11, 2002 and Thursday, December 12, 2002 for the purpose of considering government business.

The question being put on the motion, it was carried on the following division:-

La motion, mise aux voix, est adoptée par le vote suivant:-

AYES / POUR - 82

Agostino

Arnott

Baird

Barrett

Bartolucci

Beaubien

Bountrogianni

Bradley

Brown

Bryant

Caplan

Chudleigh

Clark

Cleary

Clement

Coburn

Colle

Conway

Cordiano

Crozier

Cunningham

Curling

DeFaria

Di Cocco

Dombrowsky

Duncan

Ecker

Elliott

Flaherty

Galt

Gerretsen

Gilchrist

Gill

Gravelle

Guzzo

Hardeman

Hastings

Hoy

Hudak

Jackson

Johns

Johnson

Kells

Klees

Kwinter

Lalonde

Levac

Marland

Martiniuk

Maves

Mazzilli

McDonald

McLeod

McMeekin

Miller

Molinari

Munro

Mushinski

Newman

O'Toole

Ouellette

Parsons

Peters

Phillips

Pupatello

Ramsay

Runciman

Ruprecht

Sampson

Sergio

Sorbara

Spina

Sterling

Stewart

Stockwell

Tascona

Turnbull

Wettlaufer

Wilson

Witmer

Wood

Young

NAYS / CONTRE - 5

Bisson

Kormos

Martel

Martin

Prue

With unanimous consent, on motion by Mr. Stockwell,

Avec le consentement unanime, sur la motion de M. Stockwell,

Ordered, That Standing Order 87 respecting notice of Committee hearings be suspended for the consideration of Bill Pr17, An Act respecting the Reena Foundation by the Standing Committee on Regulations and Private Bills on Wednesday, December 11, 2002.

DEFERRED VOTES

VOTES DIFFÉRÉS

The deferred vote on the motion for Third Reading of Bill 175, An Act respecting the cost of water and waste water services, was carried on the following division:-

La motion portant troisième lecture du projet de loi 175, Loi concernant le coût des services d'approvisionnement en eau et des services relatifs aux eaux usées, mise aux voix sur le vote différé, est adoptée par le vote suivant:-

AYES / POUR - 50

Arnott

Baird

Barrett

Beaubien

Chudleigh

Clark

Clement

Coburn

Cunningham

DeFaria

Ecker

Elliott

Flaherty

Galt

Gilchrist

Gill

Guzzo

Hardeman

Hastings

Hudak

Jackson

Johns

Johnson

Kells

Klees

Marland

Martiniuk

Maves

Mazzilli

McDonald

Miller

Molinari

Munro

Mushinski

Newman

O'Toole

Ouellette

Runciman

Sampson

Spina

Sterling

Stewart

Stockwell

Tascona

Turnbull

Wettlaufer

Wilson

Witmer

Wood

Young

NAYS / CONTRE - 40

Agostino

Bartolucci

Bisson

Bountrogianni

Bradley

Brown

Bryant

Caplan

Christopherson

Churley

Cleary

Colle

Conway

Cordiano

Crozier

Curling

Di Cocco

Dombrowsky

Duncan

Gerretsen

Gravelle

Hoy

Kormos

Kwinter

Lalonde

Levac

Martel

Martin

McLeod

McMeekin

Parsons

Peters

Phillips

Prue

Pupatello

Ramsay

Ruprecht

Sergio

Smitherman

Sorbara

And the Bill was accordingly read the third time and was passed.

En conséquence, ce projet de loi est lu une troisième fois et adopté.

The deferred vote on the motion for Third Reading of Bill 180, An Act to enact, amend or revise various Acts related to consumer protection, was carried on the following division:-

La motion portant troisième lecture du projet de loi 180, Loi édictant, modifiant ou révisant diverses lois portant sur la protection du consommateur, mise aux voix sur le vote différé, est adoptée par le vote suivant:-

AYES / POUR - 90

Agostino

Arnott

Baird

Barrett

Bartolucci

Beaubien

Bisson

Bountrogianni

Bradley

Brown

Bryant

Caplan

Christopherson

Chudleigh

Churley

Clark

Cleary

Clement

Coburn

Colle

Conway

Cordiano

Crozier

Cunningham

Curling

DeFaria

Di Cocco

Dombrowsky

Duncan

Ecker

Elliott

Flaherty

Galt

Gerretsen

Gilchrist

Gill

Gravelle

Guzzo

Hardeman

Hastings

Hoy

Hudak

Jackson

Johns

Johnson

Kells

Klees

Kormos

Kwinter

Lalonde

Levac

Marland

Martel

Martin

Martiniuk

Maves

Mazzilli

McDonald

McLeod

McMeekin

Miller

Molinari

Munro

Mushinski

Newman

O'Toole

Ouellette

Parsons

Peters

Phillips

Prue

Pupatello

Ramsay

Runciman

Ruprecht

Sampson

Sergio

Smitherman

Sorbara

Spina

Sterling

Stewart

Stockwell

Tascona

Turnbull

Wettlaufer

Wilson

Witmer

Wood

Young

NAYS / CONTRE - 0

And the Bill was accordingly read the third time and was passed.

En conséquence, ce projet de loi est lu une troisième fois et adopté.

The deferred vote on the motion for Third Reading of Bill 195, An Act respecting safe drinking water, was carried on the following division:-

La motion portant troisième lecture du projet de loi 195, Loi ayant trait à la salubrité de l'eau potable, mise aux voix sur le vote différé, est adoptée par le vote suivant:-

AYES / POUR - 90

Agostino

Arnott

Baird

Barrett

Bartolucci

Beaubien

Bisson

Bountrogianni

Bradley

Brown

Bryant

Caplan

Christopherson

Chudleigh

Churley

Clark

Cleary

Clement

Coburn

Colle

Conway

Cordiano

Crozier

Cunningham

Curling

DeFaria

Di Cocco

Dombrowsky

Duncan

Ecker

Elliott

Flaherty

Galt

Gerretsen

Gilchrist

Gill

Gravelle

Guzzo

Hardeman

Hastings

Hoy

Hudak

Jackson

Johns

Johnson

Kells

Klees

Kormos

Kwinter

Lalonde

Levac

Marland

Martel

Martin

Martiniuk

Maves

Mazzilli

McDonald

McLeod

McMeekin

Miller

Molinari

Munro

Mushinski

Newman

O'Toole

Ouellette

Parsons

Peters

Phillips

Prue

Pupatello

Ramsay

Runciman

Ruprecht

Sampson

Sergio

Smitherman

Sorbara

Spina

Sterling

Stewart

Stockwell

Tascona

Turnbull

Wettlaufer

Wilson

Witmer

Wood

Young

NAYS / CONTRE - 0

And the Bill was accordingly read the third time and was passed.

En conséquence, ce projet de loi est lu une troisième fois et adopté.

The deferred vote on the motion for Third Reading of Bill 209, An Act respecting funerals, burials, cremations and related services and providing for the amendment of other statutes, was carried on the following division:-

La motion portant troisième lecture du projet de loi 209, Loi traitant des funérailles, des enterrements, des crémations et des services connexes et prévoyant la modification d'autres lois, mise aux voix sur le vote différé, est adoptée par le vote suivant:-

AYES / POUR - 50

Arnott

Baird

Barrett

Beaubien

Chudleigh

Clark

Clement

Coburn

Cunningham

DeFaria

Ecker

Elliott

Flaherty

Galt

Gilchrist

Gill

Guzzo

Hardeman

Hastings

Hudak

Jackson

Johns

Johnson

Kells

Klees

Marland

Martiniuk

Maves

Mazzilli

McDonald

Miller

Molinari

Munro

Mushinski

Newman

O'Toole

Ouellette

Runciman

Sampson

Spina

Sterling

Stewart

Stockwell

Tascona

Turnbull

Wettlaufer

Wilson

Witmer

Wood

Young

NAYS / CONTRE - 40

Agostino

Bartolucci

Bisson

Bountrogianni

Bradley

Brown

Bryant

Caplan

Christopherson

Churley

Cleary

Colle

Conway

Cordiano

Crozier

Curling

Di Cocco

Dombrowsky

Duncan

Gerretsen

Gravelle

Hoy

Kormos

Kwinter

Lalonde

Levac

Martel

Martin

McLeod

McMeekin

Parsons

Peters

Phillips

Prue

Pupatello

Ramsay

Ruprecht

Sergio

Smitherman

Sorbara

And the Bill was accordingly read the third time and was passed.

En conséquence, ce projet de loi est lu une troisième fois et adopté.

With unanimous consent, the House reverted to motions.

MOTIONS

MOTIONS

With unanimous consent, Mr. Klees moved,

Avec le consentement unanime, M. Klees propose,

Whereas the Hamilton Bid for the 2010 Commonwealth Games has received the support of the Premier of Ontario, the Minister of Tourism and Recreation, the Leader of the Official Opposition, the Leader of the third party and all Hamilton MPPs. Therefore let it be resolved that the Legislative Assembly of Ontario endorse and support the City of Hamilton's bid for the 2010 Commonwealth Games.

The question having been put on Mr. Klees's Resolution, it was declared carried.

La motion, mise aux voix, sur la résolution de M. Klees est déclarée adoptée.

During "Oral Questions", the Speaker requested the Member for Sault Ste. Marie (Mr. Martin) to come to order.

Pendant la période des «Questions orales», le Président demande au député de Sault Ste. Marie, M. Martin de se comporter.

The Member having refused was named by the Speaker and directed to withdraw from the service of the House for the balance of the sessional day.

Comme le député refuse d'obéir, le Président le désigne par son nom et l'ordonne de se retirer du service de l'Assemblée pour le reste du jour de session.

During "Oral Questions", the Speaker requested the Member for Lanark-Carleton (Mr. Sterling) to come to order.

Pendant la période des «Questions orales», le Président demande au député de Lanark-Carleton, M. Sterling de se comporter.

The Member having refused was named by the Speaker and directed to withdraw from the service of the House for the balance of the sessional day.

Comme le député refuse d'obéir, le Président le désigne par son nom et l'ordonne de se retirer du service de l'Assemblée pour le reste du jour de session.

PETITIONS

PÉTITIONS

Petitions relating to Amendments to the Ontario Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act (Sessional Paper No. P-12) Mr. Hardeman and Mrs. Munro.

Petition relating to Freezing tuition fees (Sessional Paper No. P-28) Mrs. McLeod.

Petition relating to Ending the homeless situation in Ontario (Sessional Paper No. P-50) Mr. Prue.

Petition relating to Adopting a $10.00 a day child care plan / Adoption du plan pour des espaces de garderie à 10 dollars pour jour (Sessional Paper No. P-77) Ms. Martel.

Petition relating to Disallowing retroactive rate hikes granted to Union Gas by the Ontario Energy Board (Sessional Paper No. P-78) Mr. Gravelle.

Petition relating to the Abandoned aluminum smelter in Georgina Ontario (Sessional Paper No. P-105) Mr. Colle.

Petition relating to the Sections of Bill 198 that concern Pension Plan Benefits (Sessional Paper No. P-112) Mr. O'Toole.

Petition relating to the Highway 407 Corporation (Sessional Paper No. P-113) Mr. Bradley.

Petition relating to the Suspension of reviews by the Medical Review Committee (Sessional Paper No. P-115) Mr. Kormos.

Petition relating to Education funding for the Hamilton-Wentworth District School Board (Sessional Paper No. P-119) Mr. Christopherson.

Petition relating to the Disposal of untreated hazardous waste in Ontario (Sessional Paper No. P-120) Ms. Di Cocco.

Petition relating to Implementation of a tax credit for parents of students attending independent schools (Sessional Paper No. P-121) Mr. O'Toole.

ORDERS OF THE DAY

ORDRE DU JOUR

Mr. Galt moved,

M. Galt propose,

That pursuant to Standing Order 46 and notwithstanding any other Standing Order or Special Order of the House relating to Bill 216, An Act respecting access to information, the review of expenses and the accountability of Cabinet ministers, Opposition leaders and certain other persons, when Bill 216 is next called as a government order, the Speaker shall put every question necessary to dispose of the second reading stage of the bill, without further debate or amendment, at such time the bill shall be Ordered for third reading, which order may be called on that same day; and

That, when the order for third reading is called, the Speaker shall put every question necessary to dispose of this stage of the bill without further debate or amendment; and

That no deferral of the second and third reading votes pursuant to Standing Order 28(h) shall be permitted; and

That, in the case of any division relating to any proceedings on the bill, the division bell shall be limited to five minutes.

A debate arising, after some time, the motion was carried on the following division:-

Un débat s'ensuit et après quelque temps, la motion est adoptée par le vote suivant:-

AYES / POUR - 50

Arnott

Baird

Barrett

Beaubien

Chudleigh

Clark

Clement

Coburn

Cunningham

DeFaria

Dunlop

Ecker

Elliott

Flaherty

Galt

Gilchrist

Gill

Guzzo

Hardeman

Hastings

Hudak

Jackson

Johns

Johnson

Kells

Klees

Marland

Martiniuk

Maves

Mazzilli

McDonald

Miller

Molinari

Munro

Mushinski

Newman

O'Toole

Runciman

Sampson

Spina

Stewart

Stockwell

Tascona

Tsubouchi

Turnbull

Wettlaufer

Wilson

Witmer

Wood

Young

NAYS / CONTRE - 35

Agostino

Bartolucci

Bisson

Bountrogianni

Bradley

Caplan

Christopherson

Churley

Cleary

Colle

Conway

Crozier

Curling

Dombrowsky

Duncan

Gerretsen

Gravelle

Hampton

Hoy

Kennedy

Kormos

Kwinter

Lalonde

Levac

Martel

McLeod

McMeekin

Parsons

Patten

Peters

Phillips

Prue

Pupatello

Ruprecht

Smitherman

At 6:00 p.m., the question "That this House do now adjourn" was deemed to have been proposed pursuant to Standing Order 37(b).

À 18 h, la motion portant «Que la présente Assemblée ajourne les débats maintenant» est réputée avoir été proposée conformément à l'article 37(b) du Règlement.

After two matters were considered, the question was deemed to have been adopted.

Après l'étude de deux questions, la motion d'ajournement des débats est réputée avoir été adoptée.

The House then adjourned at 6:20 p.m.

À 18 h 20, la chambre a ensuite ajourné ses travaux.

6:45 P.M.

18 H 45

ORDERS OF THE DAY

ORDRE DU JOUR

With unanimous consent, Orders for Concurrence in Supply for the following Ministries and Offices were debated together:-

Avec le consentement unanime, les ordres d'adoption des budgets des dépenses des ministères et offices suivants sont débattus ensemble:-

Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care (including Supplementaries).

Adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère de la Santé et des Soins de longue durée (supplémentaires inclus).

Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Education.

Adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère de l'Éducation.

Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Environment and Energy.

Adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère de l'Environnement et de l'Énergie.

Concurrence in Supply for Office of the Premier.

Adoption du budget des dépenses du Cabinet du Premier ministre.

Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Intergovernmental Affairs.

Adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère des Affaires intergouvernementales.

Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Northern Development and Mines (including Supplementaries).

Adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère du Développement du Nord et des Mines (supplémentaires inclus).

Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Training, Colleges and Universities (including Supplementaries).

Adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère de la Formation et des Collèges et Universités (supplémentaires inclus).

Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Community, Family and Children's Services (including Supplementaries).

Adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère des Services à la collectivité, à la famille et à l'enfance (supplémentaires inclus).

Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Natural Resources.

Adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère des Richesses naturelles.

Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Public Safety and Security.

Adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère de la Sûreté et de la Sécurité publique.

Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Tourism and Recreation.

Adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère du Tourisme et des Loisirs.

Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Enterprise, Opportunity and Innovation.

Adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère de l'Entreprise, des Débouchés et de l'Innovation.

After some time, the vote on the Order for Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care (including Supplementaries) was carried on the following division:-

Après quelque temps, le vote sur l'ordre d'adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère de la Santé et des Soins de longue durée (supplémentaires inclus), mise aux voix, est adopté par le vote suivant:-

AYES / POUR - 53

Arnott

Baird

Barrett

Beaubien

Chudleigh

Clark

Clement

Coburn

DeFaria

Dunlop

Ecker

Elliott

Flaherty

Galt

Gilchrist

Gill

Guzzo

Hardeman

Hastings

Hudak

Jackson

Johns

Johnson

Kells

Klees

Marland

Martiniuk

Maves

Mazzilli

McDonald

Miller

Molinari

Munro

Murdoch

Mushinski

Newman

O'Toole

Ouellette

Runciman

Sampson

Snobelen

Spina

Sterling

Stewart

Stockwell

Tascona

Tsubouchi

Turnbull

Wettlaufer

Wilson

Witmer

Wood

Young

NAYS / CONTRE - 36

Agostino

Bartolucci

Bisson

Bountrogianni

Boyer

Bradley

Bryant

Caplan

Christopherson

Churley

Cleary

Colle

Conway

Crozier

Di Cocco

Dombrowsky

Duncan

Gerretsen

Gravelle

Hampton

Hoy

Kormos

Lalonde

Levac

Martel

Martin

McGuinty

McLeod

Parsons

Patten

Peters

Phillips

Prue

Pupatello

Ramsay

Ruprecht

And Supply was accordingly concurred in.

En conséquence, le budget des dépenses est adopté.

The vote on the Order for Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Education was carried on the following division:-

Le vote sur l'ordre d'adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère de l'Éducation, mise aux voix, est adopté par le vote suivant:-

AYES / POUR - 53

Arnott

Baird

Barrett

Beaubien

Chudleigh

Clark

Clement

Coburn

DeFaria

Dunlop

Ecker

Elliott

Flaherty

Galt

Gilchrist

Gill

Guzzo

Hardeman

Hastings

Hudak

Jackson

Johns

Johnson

Kells

Klees

Marland

Martiniuk

Maves

Mazzilli

McDonald

Miller

Molinari

Munro

Murdoch

Mushinski

Newman

O'Toole

Ouellette

Runciman

Sampson

Snobelen

Spina

Sterling

Stewart

Stockwell

Tascona

Tsubouchi

Turnbull

Wettlaufer

Wilson

Witmer

Wood

Young

NAYS / CONTRE - 36

Agostino

Bartolucci

Bisson

Bountrogianni

Boyer

Bradley

Bryant

Caplan

Christopherson

Churley

Cleary

Colle

Conway

Crozier

Di Cocco

Dombrowsky

Duncan

Gerretsen

Gravelle

Hampton

Hoy

Kormos

Lalonde

Levac

Martel

Martin

McGuinty

McLeod

Parsons

Patten

Peters

Phillips

Prue

Pupatello

Ramsay

Ruprecht

And Supply was accordingly concurred in.

En conséquence, le budget des dépenses est adopté.

The vote on the Order for Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Environment and Energy was carried on the following division:-

Le vote sur l'ordre d'adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère de l'Environnement et de l'Énergie, mise aux voix, est adopté par le vote suivant:-

AYES / POUR - 53

Arnott

Baird

Barrett

Beaubien

Chudleigh

Clark

Clement

Coburn

DeFaria

Dunlop

Ecker

Elliott

Flaherty

Galt

Gilchrist

Gill

Guzzo

Hardeman

Hastings

Hudak

Jackson

Johns

Johnson

Kells

Klees

Marland

Martiniuk

Maves

Mazzilli

McDonald

Miller

Molinari

Munro

Murdoch

Mushinski

Newman

O'Toole

Ouellette

Runciman

Sampson

Snobelen

Spina

Sterling

Stewart

Stockwell

Tascona

Tsubouchi

Turnbull

Wettlaufer

Wilson

Witmer

Wood

Young

NAYS / CONTRE - 36

Agostino

Bartolucci

Bisson

Bountrogianni

Boyer

Bradley

Bryant

Caplan

Christopherson

Churley

Cleary

Colle

Conway

Crozier

Di Cocco

Dombrowsky

Duncan

Gerretsen

Gravelle

Hampton

Hoy

Kormos

Lalonde

Levac

Martel

Martin

McGuinty

McLeod

Parsons

Patten

Peters

Phillips

Prue

Pupatello

Ramsay

Ruprecht

And Supply was accordingly concurred in.

En conséquence, le budget des dépenses est adopté.

The vote on the Order for Concurrence in Supply for the Office of the Premier was carried on the following division:-

Le vote sur l'ordre d'adoption du budget des dépenses du Cabinet du Premier ministre, mise aux voix, est adopté par le vote suivant:-

AYES / POUR - 53

Arnott

Baird

Barrett

Beaubien

Chudleigh

Clark

Clement

Coburn

DeFaria

Dunlop

Ecker

Elliott

Flaherty

Galt

Gilchrist

Gill

Guzzo

Hardeman

Hastings

Hudak

Jackson

Johns

Johnson

Kells

Klees

Marland

Martiniuk

Maves

Mazzilli

McDonald

Miller

Molinari

Munro

Murdoch

Mushinski

Newman

O'Toole

Ouellette

Runciman

Sampson

Snobelen

Spina

Sterling

Stewart

Stockwell

Tascona

Tsubouchi

Turnbull

Wettlaufer

Wilson

Witmer

Wood

Young

NAYS / CONTRE - 36

Agostino

Bartolucci

Bisson

Bountrogianni

Boyer

Bradley

Bryant

Caplan

Christopherson

Churley

Cleary

Colle

Conway

Crozier

Di Cocco

Dombrowsky

Duncan

Gerretsen

Gravelle

Hampton

Hoy

Kormos

Lalonde

Levac

Martel

Martin

McGuinty

McLeod

Parsons

Patten

Peters

Phillips

Prue

Pupatello

Ramsay

Ruprecht

And Supply was accordingly concurred in.

En conséquence, le budget des dépenses est adopté.

The vote on the Order for Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Intergovernmental Affairs was carried on the following division:-

Le vote sur l'ordre d'adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère des Affaires intergouvernementales, mise aux voix, est adopté par le vote suivant:-

AYES / POUR - 53

Arnott

Baird

Barrett

Beaubien

Chudleigh

Clark

Clement

Coburn

DeFaria

Dunlop

Ecker

Elliott

Flaherty

Galt

Gilchrist

Gill

Guzzo

Hardeman

Hastings

Hudak

Jackson

Johns

Johnson

Kells

Klees

Marland

Martiniuk

Maves

Mazzilli

McDonald

Miller

Molinari

Munro

Murdoch

Mushinski

Newman

O'Toole

Ouellette

Runciman

Sampson

Snobelen

Spina

Sterling

Stewart

Stockwell

Tascona

Tsubouchi

Turnbull

Wettlaufer

Wilson

Witmer

Wood

Young

NAYS / CONTRE - 36

Agostino

Bartolucci

Bisson

Bountrogianni

Boyer

Bradley

Bryant

Caplan

Christopherson

Churley

Cleary

Colle

Conway

Crozier

Di Cocco

Dombrowsky

Duncan

Gerretsen

Gravelle

Hampton

Hoy

Kormos

Lalonde

Levac

Martel

Martin

McGuinty

McLeod

Parsons

Patten

Peters

Phillips

Prue

Pupatello

Ramsay

Ruprecht

And Supply was accordingly concurred in.

En conséquence, le budget des dépenses est adopté.

The vote on the Order for Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Northern Development and Mines (including Supplementaries) was carried on the following division:-

Le vote sur l'ordre d'adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère du Développement du Nord et des Mines (supplémentaires inclus), mise aux voix, est adopté par le vote suivant:-

AYES / POUR - 53

Arnott

Baird

Barrett

Beaubien

Chudleigh

Clark

Clement

Coburn

DeFaria

Dunlop

Ecker

Elliott

Flaherty

Galt

Gilchrist

Gill

Guzzo

Hardeman

Hastings

Hudak

Jackson

Johns

Johnson

Kells

Klees

Marland

Martiniuk

Maves

Mazzilli

McDonald

Miller

Molinari

Munro

Murdoch

Mushinski

Newman

O'Toole

Ouellette

Runciman

Sampson

Snobelen

Spina

Sterling

Stewart

Stockwell

Tascona

Tsubouchi

Turnbull

Wettlaufer

Wilson

Witmer

Wood

Young

NAYS / CONTRE - 36

Agostino

Bartolucci

Bisson

Bountrogianni

Boyer

Bradley

Bryant

Caplan

Christopherson

Churley

Cleary

Colle

Conway

Crozier

Di Cocco

Dombrowsky

Duncan

Gerretsen

Gravelle

Hampton

Hoy

Kormos

Lalonde

Levac

Martel

Martin

McGuinty

McLeod

Parsons

Patten

Peters

Phillips

Prue

Pupatello

Ramsay

Ruprecht

And Supply was accordingly concurred in.

En conséquence, le budget des dépenses est adopté.

The vote on the Order for Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Training, Colleges and Universities (including Supplementaries) was carried on the following division:-

Le vote sur l'ordre d'adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère de la Formation et des Collèges et Universités (supplémentaires inclus), mise aux voix, est adopté par le vote suivant:-

AYES / POUR - 53

Arnott

Baird

Barrett

Beaubien

Chudleigh

Clark

Clement

Coburn

DeFaria

Dunlop

Ecker

Elliott

Flaherty

Galt

Gilchrist

Gill

Guzzo

Hardeman

Hastings

Hudak

Jackson

Johns

Johnson

Kells

Klees

Marland

Martiniuk

Maves

Mazzilli

McDonald

Miller

Molinari

Munro

Murdoch

Mushinski

Newman

O'Toole

Ouellette

Runciman

Sampson

Snobelen

Spina

Sterling

Stewart

Stockwell

Tascona

Tsubouchi

Turnbull

Wettlaufer

Wilson

Witmer

Wood

Young

NAYS / CONTRE - 36

Agostino

Bartolucci

Bisson

Bountrogianni

Boyer

Bradley

Bryant

Caplan

Christopherson

Churley

Cleary

Colle

Conway

Crozier

Di Cocco

Dombrowsky

Duncan

Gerretsen

Gravelle

Hampton

Hoy

Kormos

Lalonde

Levac

Martel

Martin

McGuinty

McLeod

Parsons

Patten

Peters

Phillips

Prue

Pupatello

Ramsay

Ruprecht

And Supply was accordingly concurred in.

En conséquence, le budget des dépenses est adopté.

The vote on the Order for Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Community, Family and Children's Services (including Supplementaries) was carried on the following division:-

Le vote sur l'ordre d'adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère des Services à la collectivité, à la famille et à l'enfance (supplémentaires inclus), mise aux voix, est adopté par le vote suivant:-

AYES / POUR - 53

Arnott

Baird

Barrett

Beaubien

Chudleigh

Clark

Clement

Coburn

DeFaria

Dunlop

Ecker

Elliott

Flaherty

Galt

Gilchrist

Gill

Guzzo

Hardeman

Hastings

Hudak

Jackson

Johns

Johnson

Kells

Klees

Marland

Martiniuk

Maves

Mazzilli

McDonald

Miller

Molinari

Munro

Murdoch

Mushinski

Newman

O'Toole

Ouellette

Runciman

Sampson

Snobelen

Spina

Sterling

Stewart

Stockwell

Tascona

Tsubouchi

Turnbull

Wettlaufer

Wilson

Witmer

Wood

Young

NAYS / CONTRE - 36

Agostino

Bartolucci

Bisson

Bountrogianni

Boyer

Bradley

Bryant

Caplan

Christopherson

Churley

Cleary

Colle

Conway

Crozier

Di Cocco

Dombrowsky

Duncan

Gerretsen

Gravelle

Hampton

Hoy

Kormos

Lalonde

Levac

Martel

Martin

McGuinty

McLeod

Parsons

Patten

Peters

Phillips

Prue

Pupatello

Ramsay

Ruprecht

And Supply was accordingly concurred in.

En conséquence, le budget des dépenses est adopté.

The vote on the Order for Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Natural Resources was carried on the following division:-

Le vote sur l'ordre d'adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère des Richesses naturelles, mise aux voix, est adopté par le vote suivant:-

AYES / POUR - 53

Arnott

Baird

Barrett

Beaubien

Chudleigh

Clark

Clement

Coburn

DeFaria

Dunlop

Ecker

Elliott

Flaherty

Galt

Gilchrist

Gill

Guzzo

Hardeman

Hastings

Hudak

Jackson

Johns

Johnson

Kells

Klees

Marland

Martiniuk

Maves

Mazzilli

McDonald

Miller

Molinari

Munro

Murdoch

Mushinski

Newman

O'Toole

Ouellette

Runciman

Sampson

Snobelen

Spina

Sterling

Stewart

Stockwell

Tascona

Tsubouchi

Turnbull

Wettlaufer

Wilson

Witmer

Wood

Young

NAYS / CONTRE - 36

Agostino

Bartolucci

Bisson

Bountrogianni

Boyer

Bradley

Bryant

Caplan

Christopherson

Churley

Cleary

Colle

Conway

Crozier

Di Cocco

Dombrowsky

Duncan

Gerretsen

Gravelle

Hampton

Hoy

Kormos

Lalonde

Levac

Martel

Martin

McGuinty

McLeod

Parsons

Patten

Peters

Phillips

Prue

Pupatello

Ramsay

Ruprecht

And Supply was accordingly concurred in.

En conséquence, le budget des dépenses est adopté.

The vote on the Order for Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Public Safety and Security was carried on the following division:-

Le vote sur l'ordre d'adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère de la Sûreté et de la Sécurité publique, mise aux voix, est adopté par le vote suivant:-

AYES / POUR - 53

Arnott

Baird

Barrett

Beaubien

Chudleigh

Clark

Clement

Coburn

DeFaria

Dunlop

Ecker

Elliott

Flaherty

Galt

Gilchrist

Gill

Guzzo

Hardeman

Hastings

Hudak

Jackson

Johns

Johnson

Kells

Klees

Marland

Martiniuk

Maves

Mazzilli

McDonald

Miller

Molinari

Munro

Murdoch

Mushinski

Newman

O'Toole

Ouellette

Runciman

Sampson

Snobelen

Spina

Sterling

Stewart

Stockwell

Tascona

Tsubouchi

Turnbull

Wettlaufer

Wilson

Witmer

Wood

Young

NAYS / CONTRE - 36

Agostino

Bartolucci

Bisson

Bountrogianni

Boyer

Bradley

Bryant

Caplan

Christopherson

Churley

Cleary

Colle

Conway

Crozier

Di Cocco

Dombrowsky

Duncan

Gerretsen

Gravelle

Hampton

Hoy

Kormos

Lalonde

Levac

Martel

Martin

McGuinty

McLeod

Parsons

Patten

Peters

Phillips

Prue

Pupatello

Ramsay

Ruprecht

And Supply was accordingly concurred in.

En conséquence, le budget des dépenses est adopté.

The vote on the Order for Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Tourism and Recreation was carried on the following division:-

Le vote sur l'ordre d'adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère du Tourisme et des Loisirs, mise aux voix, est adopté par le vote suivant:-

AYES / POUR - 53

Arnott

Baird

Barrett

Beaubien

Chudleigh

Clark

Clement

Coburn

DeFaria

Dunlop

Ecker

Elliott

Flaherty

Galt

Gilchrist

Gill

Guzzo

Hardeman

Hastings

Hudak

Jackson

Johns

Johnson

Kells

Klees

Marland

Martiniuk

Maves

Mazzilli

McDonald

Miller

Molinari

Munro

Murdoch

Mushinski

Newman

O'Toole

Ouellette

Runciman

Sampson

Snobelen

Spina

Sterling

Stewart

Stockwell

Tascona

Tsubouchi

Turnbull

Wettlaufer

Wilson

Witmer

Wood

Young

NAYS / CONTRE - 36

Agostino

Bartolucci

Bisson

Bountrogianni

Boyer

Bradley

Bryant

Caplan

Christopherson

Churley

Cleary

Colle

Conway

Crozier

Di Cocco

Dombrowsky

Duncan

Gerretsen

Gravelle

Hampton

Hoy

Kormos

Lalonde

Levac

Martel

Martin

McGuinty

McLeod

Parsons

Patten

Peters

Phillips

Prue

Pupatello

Ramsay

Ruprecht

And Supply was accordingly concurred in.

En conséquence, le budget des dépenses est adopté.

The vote on the Order for Concurrence in Supply for the Ministry of Enterprise, Opportunity and Innovation was carried on the following division:-

Le vote sur l'ordre d'adoption du budget des dépenses du ministère de l'Entreprise, des Débouchés et de l'Innovation, mise aux voix, est adopté par le vote suivant:-

AYES / POUR - 53

Arnott

Baird

Barrett

Beaubien

Chudleigh

Clark

Clement

Coburn

DeFaria

Dunlop

Ecker

Elliott

Flaherty

Galt

Gilchrist

Gill

Guzzo

Hardeman

Hastings

Hudak

Jackson

Johns

Johnson

Kells

Klees

Marland

Martiniuk

Maves

Mazzilli

McDonald

Miller

Molinari

Munro

Murdoch

Mushinski

Newman

O'Toole

Ouellette

Runciman

Sampson

Snobelen

Spina

Sterling

Stewart

Stockwell

Tascona

Tsubouchi

Turnbull

Wettlaufer

Wilson

Witmer

Wood

Young

NAYS / CONTRE - 36

Agostino

Bartolucci

Bisson

Bountrogianni

Boyer

Bradley

Bryant

Caplan

Christopherson

Churley

Cleary

Colle

Conway

Crozier

Di Cocco

Dombrowsky

Duncan

Gerretsen

Gravelle

Hampton

Hoy

Kormos

Lalonde

Levac

Martel

Martin

McGuinty

McLeod

Parsons

Patten

Peters

Phillips

Prue

Pupatello

Ramsay

Ruprecht

And Supply was accordingly concurred in.

En conséquence, le budget des dépenses est adopté.

Debate was resumed on the motion for Third Reading of Bill 30, An Act to amend the Fire Protection and Prevention Act, 1997 in order to protect the employment of volunteer firefighters.

Le débat reprend sur la motion portant troisième lecture du projet de loi loi 30, Loi modifiant la Loi de 1997 sur la prévention et la protection contre l'incendie afin de protéger l'emploi des pompiers volontaires.

On a point of order being raised, the Acting Speaker (Mr. Brown) recessed the House for 5 minutes.

After some time, Mr. Wilson moved under Standing Order 47 "That this question be now put", which motion was carried on the following division:-

Après quelque temps, M. Wilson propose «Que cette question soit maintenant mise aux voix» conformément à l'article 47 du Règlement et ladite motion est adoptée par le vote suivant:-

AYES / POUR - 47

Arnott

Baird

Barrett

Beaubien

Chudleigh

Clark

Clement

Coburn

Cunningham

DeFaria

Ecker

Elliott

Galt

Gilchrist

Gill

Guzzo

Hardeman

Hastings

Hudak

Jackson

Johns

Johnson

Kells

Klees

Marland

Martiniuk

Maves

Mazzilli

McDonald

Miller

Molinari

Munro

Murdoch

Newman

O'Toole

Sampson

Snobelen

Spina

Sterling

Stockwell

Tascona

Tsubouchi

Turnbull

Wettlaufer

Wilson

Witmer

Young

NAYS / CONTRE - 30

Agostino

Bartolucci

Bisson

Bountrogianni

Boyer

Bradley

Brown

Caplan

Christopherson

Churley

Colle

Conway

Crozier

Dombrowsky

Gerretsen

Gravelle

Hampton

Hoy

Kormos

Lalonde

Levac

Martel

Martin

McMeekin

Patten

Peters

Prue

Ramsay

Ruprecht

Wood

The Speaker then put the question on the motion for Third Reading of Bill 30, An Act to amend the Fire Protection and Prevention Act, 1997 in order to protect the employment of volunteer firefighters, and declared his opinion that the Ayes had it, and a recorded vote having been demanded,

Ensuite, le Président met la motion portant troisième lecture du projet de loi 30, Loi modifiant la Loi de 1997 sur la prévention et la protection contre l'incendie afin de protéger l'emploi des pompiers volontaires, aux voix, et déclare qu'à son avis les voix favorables l'emportent et un vote par appel nominal a été demandé,

The Speaker directed that the Members be called in, for which purpose the division bells were rung.

Le Président donne des directives pour convoquer les députés et la sonnerie d'appel se fait entendre.

During the ringing of the bells, the Speaker addressed the House as follows:-

Pendant la sonnerie d'appel, le Président s'adresse à l'Assemblée en ces mots:-

I have received a request from the Chief Government Whip, under Standing Order 28(h), that the vote on Bill 30, An Act to amend the Fire Protection and Prevention Act, 1997 in order to protect the employment of volunteer firefighters, be deferred until December 11, 2002.

J'ai reçu une requête du Whip en chef du gouvernement, conformément à l'article 28(h) du Règlement, que le vote sur la motion portant troisième lecture du projet de loi 30, Loi modifiant la Loi de 1997 sur la prévention et la protection contre l'incendie afin de protéger l'emploi des pompiers volontaires, soit différé jusqu'au 11 décembre 2002.

Therefore the vote is accordingly deferred.

En conséquence, le vote est différé.

A debate arose on the motion for Third Reading of Bill 129, An Act to amend the Ontario Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act.

Il s'élève un débat sur la motion portant troisième lecture du projet de loi 129, Loi modifiant la Loi sur la Société de protection des animaux de l'Ontario.

After some time, pursuant to Standing Order 9(a), the motion for the adjournment of the debate was deemed to have been made and carried.

Après quelque temps, conformément à l'article 9(a) du Règlement, la motion d'ajournement du débat est réputée avoir été proposée et adoptée.

The House then adjourned at 12:00 midnight.

À minuit, la chambre a ensuite ajourné ses travaux.

le président

GARY CARR

Speaker

PETITIONS TABLED PURSUANT TO STANDING ORDER 38 (A)

Petition relating to Disallowing retroactive rate hikes granted to Union Gas by the Ontario Energy Board (Sessional Paper No. P-78) Mr. Duncan.